What’s Better in Ontario: A Charity or a Not-for-profit?

If you’re starting an organization in Ontario to address a social cause, you’ve likely come across two common structures: charities and not-for-profits. While they may seem similar, they have key differences in terms of purpose, regulations, and tax treatment. So, which one is better for your goals? Let’s break down the details to help you make an informed decision.

What is a Charity?

A charity is an organization whose primary purpose is to benefit the public by addressing one of four broad categories:

1. Relief of poverty – Supporting individuals or families struggling financially.
2. Advancement of education – Promoting education through programs, schools, or scholarships.
3. Advancement of religion – Religious organizations or places of worship providing spiritual support.
4. Other purposes beneficial to the community – This could include health, animal welfare, environmental protection, or the promotion of the arts.

In Canada, charities must be registered with the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) to issue tax receipts to donors and access tax exemptions. The CRA has strict rules regarding how charities operate, particularly around funding and activities. For example, charities can only engage in activities directly related to their mission, and there are limits on political activities they can pursue. A charity's focus must always be on public benefit rather than individual or private gain.

What is a Not-for-profit?

A not-for-profit (NFP) organization is one that operates to provide services, activities, or benefits to its members. Unlike charities, NFPs don’t necessarily need to serve the general public. Instead, they can focus on specific groups like sports clubs, hobby groups, or professional associations.

While NFPs can make a profit, any surplus must be reinvested into the organization’s objectives rather than being distributed to members or directors. NFPs also face fewer regulations compared to charities when it comes to their activities. However, they cannot issue tax receipts to donors and are typically not eligible for the same tax exemptions as charities.

Key Differences Between Charities and Not-for-profits in Ontario

1. Tax Treatment

Charities: Registered charities enjoy tax-exempt status and can issue donation receipts that allow donors to claim a tax deduction. This can be a powerful incentive for individuals and corporations to contribute.

Not-for-profits: NFPs do not qualify for tax exemptions or the ability to issue charitable donation receipts, which could make fundraising more challenging.

2. Regulation and Oversight

Charities: Charities are subject to strict regulation by the CRA. They are required to file annual information returns, detailing how funds are used to ensure compliance with their charitable purpose.

Not-for-profits: NFPs, on the other hand, have less oversight and flexibility in their operations. They must still comply with Ontario’s Not-for-Profit Corporations Act (ONCA), but their reporting requirements are typically less onerous than those for charities.

3. Purpose and Mission

Charities: A charity’s primary purpose must be for the public benefit, and it must focus on activities related to one of the four charitable purposes mentioned earlier.

Not-for-profits: NFPs can focus on member benefits, such as supporting a particular group or community, and do not need to demonstrate public benefit in the same way that charities do.

4. Political Activities

Charities: The CRA allows charities to engage in political activities, but these activities must align with their charitable mission.

Not-for-profits: NFPs have more freedom in political activities. They are not restricted by the CRA’s rules on political engagement, making it easier for them to engage in lobbying or advocacy on behalf of their members.

5. Funding and Donations

Charities: Charities have an advantage when it comes to donations. Because they can issue tax receipts, individuals and corporations are often more willing to donate.

Not-for-profits: NFPs may find it harder to raise funds since they can’t offer tax benefits to donors. They often rely on membership fees, grants, or sponsorships.

Which is Right for You?

When deciding between forming a charity or a not-for-profit in Ontario, consider the following:

• Your Mission: If your goal is to benefit the general public and you need to rely on donations, a charity might be the better option. If your organization is primarily focused on serving a specific group of people, such as members of a club or association, a not-for-profit may be more suitable.
• Regulation: If you’re comfortable with the stricter regulations and reporting requirements of a charity, the tax benefits and ability to issue donation receipts may outweigh the administrative burden. However, if you prefer more operational freedom and less oversight, a not-for-profit might offer more flexibility.
• Fundraising Strategy: Consider your funding model. Charities have an edge in attracting donations because of tax receipts, but NFPs may excel with membership-based income or government grants tailored to specific sectors.

There is no one-size-fits-all answer to whether a charity or not-for-profit is better in Ontario. It depends on your organization’s purpose, target audience, and funding needs. Understanding the legal and financial differences will help you choose the structure that best aligns with your goals. If you’re unsure, consulting with a charity lawyer in Ontario can provide valuable guidance.

‍