What is Director and Officer Liability for Charities in Canada?

In Canada, individuals who serve as directors and officers for charities play a vital role in ensuring the organization runs smoothly and adheres to legal and ethical guidelines. However, many people don't realize that these roles come with potential personal liabilities. Understanding director and officer liability is crucial for anyone involved in running a charity, as failure to comply with regulations can lead to personal legal consequences.

Who Are the Directors and Officers?

Directors are the individuals who sit on the board of a charity. They are responsible for making high-level decisions, setting policies, and overseeing the organization’s activities. Officers, on the other hand, are typically appointed by the board to handle the charity's day-to-day operations, such as a CEO, CFO, or Executive Director.

In many cases, directors and officers are volunteers who serve out of passion for the cause. However, the responsibilities they carry can put them at risk for personal liability if the organization fails to comply with the law.

The Legal Obligations of Directors and Officers

Directors and officers must fulfill several legal duties under Canadian law:

1. Duty of Care: Directors and officers must act prudently and diligently. This means they must make informed decisions and consider the best interests of the charity at all times. For example, a director should attend board meetings regularly and actively participate in decision-making.
2. Duty of Loyalty: They must avoid conflicts of interest and always put the charity’s interests first. For instance, if a director has a business that could benefit from a charity’s decision, they must disclose this conflict and avoid participating in related decisions.
3. Duty of Obedience: Directors and officers must ensure the charity complies with all applicable laws and regulations, including maintaining its charitable status. This involves following the rules set by federal and provincial governments as well as adhering to the charity's bylaws.

What Can Directors and Officers Be Liable For?

There are several areas where directors and officers can face personal liability if the charity does not meet its legal obligations:

1. Financial Mismanagement: Directors and officers may be held personally liable for unpaid taxes, including GST/HST, or for failing to remit employee payroll deductions. For example, if a charity does not send the appropriate tax payments to the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), directors could be personally responsible for the debt.
2. Non-Compliance with Laws: Charities must adhere to a range of federal and provincial regulations, including those related to employment, privacy, and health and safety. If the charity violates these laws, directors and officers may face fines or other penalties.
3. Improper Use of Charitable Funds: Directors and officers must ensure that funds are used for the charity’s stated mission. If funds are misused, such as being spent on activities unrelated to the charity’s objectives, directors could be held accountable.
4. Negligence or Breach of Duty: Directors can be held liable for failing to meet their duties of care, loyalty, or obedience. For example, if a director fails to supervise the organization’s activities and this leads to harm (such as mismanagement of funds), they could face personal lawsuits.

How Can Directors and Officers Protect Themselves?

Understanding the potential liabilities is the first step in protecting oneself as a director or officer of a charity. Here are some practical ways to mitigate these risks:

1. Education and Training: Directors and officers should undergo training to fully understand their legal obligations. Many organizations, like Capacity Canada, provide workshops on governance, compliance, and risk management for charities.
2. Board Governance Best Practices: It is crucial to establish clear policies and procedures. This involves setting up systems for financial oversight, holding regular board meetings, and maintaining detailed records of decisions.
3. D&O Insurance: Directors and officers can safeguard themselves from personal liability by obtaining Directors and Officers (D&O) insurance. This insurance type helps cover legal costs and damages resulting from lawsuits or claims of misconduct.
4. Legal and Financial Expertise: It is advisable for charities to involve legal and financial professionals who can offer guidance on complying with federal and provincial laws. This includes regular audits and legal reviews to ensure the charity is fulfilling all its obligations.
5. Conflict of Interest Policies: Implementing a clear conflict of interest policy can help prevent situations where directors or officers could be liable for decisions that benefit themselves over the charity.

How Do Canadian Laws Affect Charity Directors and Officers?

In Canada, charity directors and officers are subject to both federal and provincial laws, depending on where the charity operates. For example, the Canada Not-for-Profit Corporations Act (CNCA) governs federally incorporated charities, while provinces like Ontario have their own laws, such as the Ontario Not-for-Profit Corporations Act (ONCA). These laws outline the specific responsibilities of directors and officers and the penalties for failing to meet them.

It’s important for charity leaders to be aware of which laws apply to their organization. For example, federally incorporated charities must file annual returns with the CRA, while provincially incorporated charities may have different filing requirements. Understanding these differences is key to avoiding penalties and staying compliant.

Serving as a director or officer for a charity in Canada is a rewarding experience, but it comes with significant responsibilities and potential liabilities. Directors and officers must fulfill their legal duties, ensure compliance with laws, and protect the charity’s resources. By staying informed, implementing best practices, and securing appropriate insurance, charity leaders can minimize their risk and continue to support their cause with confidence.

‍