What's Better in British Columbia: A Charity or a Not-for-profit?

When deciding to start an organization in British Columbia (BC) generally, or Vancouver specifically, understanding the difference between a charity and a not-for-profit organization (NPO) is essential. While both are designed to serve the community, the structure, tax benefits, and regulatory obligations of each differ significantly. This guide will walk you through these distinctions and help you make the right decision for your cause.

What’s the Main Difference Between a Charity and a Not-for-profit?

Both charities and not-for-profits serve public interests, but they differ primarily in their purpose and tax treatment. In BC, the primary differences include:

• Charity: A charity must have specific charitable purposes (such as advancing education, relieving poverty, or supporting religious activities) and operate to benefit the public. Charities are eligible for special tax benefits, including issuing tax-deductible donation receipts.
• Not-for-profit (NPO): An NPO can serve a broader range of purposes, including cultural, social, or recreational, but cannot issue tax-deductible receipts. The income of NPOs cannot benefit any members or stakeholders.

Legal Structure and Registration

In British Columbia, charities must be registered with the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) to issue official donation receipts. The CRA ensures that charities operate under strict rules and meet the requirements for charitable registration, such as having charitable purposes and conducting activities exclusively for charitable goals.

NPOs, on the other hand, do not require CRA registration for tax exemption, though they still need to follow certain rules to maintain their tax-exempt status. They are often formed as societies under the British Columbia Societies Act or as Not-for-Profit Corporations under the CNCA. Unlike charities, NPOs cannot benefit from tax-deductible donations but still enjoy tax-exempt status on income if they meet the necessary conditions.

Tax Benefits

The tax benefits available to charities in BC are one of the most significant advantages of choosing this structure. Charities can issue tax receipts to donors, which can reduce the donor's taxable income. This incentive often helps charities raise more funds from individual and corporate donors.

NPOs, however, cannot issue these receipts, making it potentially harder to attract large donations. Still, NPOs are exempt from paying income taxes on their revenues if they meet the required conditions, but they don’t offer tax benefits to donors.

Purpose and Operations

In British Columbia, charities are limited to charitable purposes as defined by the CRA, such as:

• Relieving poverty
• Advancing education
• Advancing religion
• Benefiting the community in a way the law regards as charitable (e.g., supporting public health, the environment, or arts)

NPOs in BC, on the other hand, have more flexibility. They can pursue recreational, social, or cultural objectives and are not restricted to charitable causes. For example, a sports club or a local theater group could be set up as an NPO.

Fundraising and Revenue Generation

For charities in BC, donations are a key source of funding. The ability to issue tax-deductible donation receipts is a significant advantage for attracting individual and corporate donors. Charities may also receive grants from governments or private foundations specifically allocated to charitable purposes.

NPOs in BC may still receive donations, but without the tax-deductible benefit, they typically rely more on membership fees, event revenue, and sponsorships. NPOs may engage in some business activities, but these must be aligned with their purpose and not primarily aim at making profits.

Accountability and Compliance

The CRA closely monitors registered charities in BC to ensure they follow strict guidelines, particularly regarding how donations are spent. Charities are required to file an annual T3010 form with detailed financial information, which is made available to the public.

NPOs, while less regulated, still have reporting obligations. They must maintain proper books and records and file annual financial reports under the BC Societies Act. Additionally, NPOs must ensure they remain tax-exempt by not distributing income to members.

Should You Start a Charity or a Not-for-profit in British Columbia?

The choice between starting a charity or a not-for-profit organization in BC depends on the nature of your mission and your funding strategy. If your primary goal aligns with charitable purposes and you plan to raise funds through donations, a charity may be the better choice because of the tax benefits for donors. However, this comes with greater regulatory oversight and a more restricted operational focus.

If your organization is more focused on community activities, recreation, or cultural pursuits and does not need to rely on large donations, an NPO might be a better fit. NPOs enjoy more operational flexibility and face less stringent oversight.

Key Takeaways

• Charities in BC must serve charitable purposes and offer tax-deductible receipts, but they face stricter regulatory requirements.
• NPOs offer greater flexibility in their activities but do not benefit from the ability to issue tax receipts, limiting their fundraising capabilities.
• Both charities and NPOs enjoy tax-exempt status on income if they comply with legal requirements.
• Choosing the right structure for your organization depends on your mission, funding needs, and willingness to adhere to specific regulatory guidelines.

Choosing whether to start a charity or a not-for-profit in British Columbia or Vancouver involves careful consideration of your organization's goals, how you plan to raise funds, and your tolerance for regulatory oversight. A charity might be the best fit if your mission aligns with a charitable purpose and you aim to raise significant funds from donors. Alternatively, an NPO provides more flexibility in activities while still serving the community.

‍